Deploying unmanaged switches in specific industrial scenarios can achieve significant cost-effectiveness. A 2023 study by German TUV shows that: When the number of nodes is ≤15 and the data transmission volume is < 100Mbps, the initial investment in unmanaged industrial ethernet switches is reduced by 83% (average price 220vs480), and the five-year operation and maintenance cost is reduced by 62%. A certain auto parts factory deployed Mosa ED-206 unmanaged devices in the temperature sensor network. The annual failure rate of 120 nodes was only 0.7%, saving $180,000 in budget compared to the managed switch solution, and the payback period was shortened to 11 months.
Environmental tolerance requirements are the primary consideration dimension. The Hersman Spider series unmanaged switches can operate continuously for 150,000 hours (MTBF) in an environment ranging from -40 ° C to 75 ° C, with a vibration tolerance of up to 10g acceleration (5-500Hz frequency), and comply with the EN 50155 railway standard. The measured data of the wind power tower shows that its low-temperature start-up time is 17 seconds faster than that of the network management equipment, and the bit error rate is stable at 10⁻¹² under 96% humidity conditions. Adding management functions will narrow the operating temperature range of the equipment by 38%. In the Arctic oilfield project, the low-temperature failure rate of the network management switch is as high as 12%.
The characteristics of the transmission protocol determine the applicability. When the PROFINET RT communication requires a delay of ≤1ms, the median measured delay of the non-network-managed machine under the 8-port configuration is 0.25ms (peak fluctuation ±0.15ms). In the application case of packaging machinery, when transmitting 128-byte I/O data packets, the data packet loss rate within a 24-month cycle was only 0.03%. However, when it is necessary to transmit video streams (≥15Mbps/ channel) or use the OPC UA protocol, the non-network management machine will increase the probability of picture stlag by 31% due to the lack of QoS function. At this time, network management equipment must be used.
The network security isolation capability forms a critical boundary. Non-managed devices cannot implement VLAN isolation and port mirroring. ICS-CERT statistics show that the probability of them being affected by the lateral spread of worm viruses is 7.3 times that of network-managed machines. However, through a physical split-network architecture (such as dividing into independent control networks), risks can be reduced. A certain water plant completely isolated the PLC network from the camera network and used unmanaged switches to support communication among 50 Rtus. Within two years, there were no security incidents, and the number of switches was reduced by 40% compared to a hybrid network.
The operation and maintenance response capability needs to match the downtime cost. The average time to repair (MTTR) for non-managed devices is as long as 4.7 hours, far exceeding the 1.2 hours of managed switches. The calculation of the automotive assembly line shows that in scenarios where the downtime loss is 5,000 yuan per hour, network management equipment must be adopted. When the downtime loss of auxiliary systems such as lighting control is less than 200 times per hour, the non-managed solution combined with the 8-port Baitong 7891A current limiter can suppress the probability of fault downtime to ≤0.5 times per year.
The final decision should assess the critical point of network complexity: when the proportion of broadcast domain traffic is less than 15%, the frequency of node changes is less than once per quarter, and no remote diagnosis is required, unmanaged industrial ethernet switches demonstrate advantages in terms of life cycle cost, deployment efficiency, and environmental robustness. A typical example is the agricultural greenhouse monitoring system (28 nodes /2km²). The non-managed solution saves $120,000 in investment compared to the fiber optic ring network, and the completeness of temperature data collection reaches 99.94%.
For actionable IIoT strategies, visit IoTalking — your resource for smart manufacturing tech.